I love the rustic look so much! Before I started these cookies, I had a technique in mind to try.....and in the middle of the experiment, I accidently scraped some of the color off the top of the cookie and realized.....THAT'S IT! That's the look I was going for. :)
To make tag cookies, you can use just about any shape and then use a straw to cut out a hole on one side of the shape. For these particular cookies, I used the tea bag cutter from That's A Nice Cookie Cutter designed for me to complete the Tea Time for Mom Decorated Cookie Collection. It has a tag hole built right into the cutter.
Brush the paint roughly over the cookie making sure it is not uniform in order to give it that rustic, primitive look.
Then....here's the fun discover......use a small knife or thin flat surfaced tool to scrape random parts of the painted color off the tag.
Also, if you'd like to add a shape on top of the tag, find a correctly sized mini cookie cutter and press it into the still wet "paint" to make an impression you can use later to pipe the shape with glaze. (see photo below)
Allow the cookie to dry for at least an hour and then outline and flood the shape over the top of the painted surface.
If desired, you can add an aged-look to the piped shape once it has dried overnight by brushing it with dry brown dust.